Connect with us through our social channels
In clinical practice, I am often asked about the nutritional value of non-dairy plant milks (NDPMs). This question usually comes up during office visits when the parents have religious or dietary preferences which exclude dairy or when toddlers and young children have cow’s milk protein allergy or lactose intolerance. Although many people are indeed lactose intolerant, some research shows that even those with this condition can tolerate some milk as long as intake is spread throughout the day.3,4 Fortunately, there have been many studies and comprehensive reviews over the past few years comparing the nutritional value of NDPMs with cow’s milk that can be of assistance to clinicians in providing patients and their families with the best evidence-based guidance.
Commercially, the most commonly found NDPMs include those made from soybeans, rice, nuts (almond, walnut, hazelnut, and cashew), coconut, oats, hemp, and flax .3,4,6,7 When advising patients and clients, one should emphasize the importance of consuming products fortified with calcium and vitamin D, and perhaps also vitamin A, C, riboflavin, and B12.3,6 Of the various NDPMs, only soymilk (8g) and pea milk (7g) have a protein content similar to cow’s milk. Most other NDPMs typically have one quarter to one half the amount of protein of soy and cow’s milk.5,6 However, plant milks fortified with isolated forms of plant protein so that their protein content is similar to cow’s milk have become available recently.
In addition to providing a similar amount of protein as cow’s milk, the quality of soy protein is similar to the quality of cow’s milk protein. Protein digestibility-corrected amino acid scores for soy protein range from about 0.95 to 1.0. The quality of soy protein is much better than the quality of the plant proteins found in other NDPMs (see table below).8,9
Aside from their role in meeting nutrient needs, there may be other benefits to consuming NDPMs although whether this is the case will depend upon the type of NDPM consumed and how it is processed. For example, soymilk has been shown to lower cholesterol levels10 and blood pressure.11 Patients may not share that they use NDPMs instead of dairy milk, so having a good understanding about these alternatives can help inform a discussion about dietary habits and, in my experience, is very well-received by the patient.
Beth Smolko, DMSc, PA-C is director-at-large for the American Academy of PAs, president of the global non-profit The Heart of Medicine, and founding PA program director for Frostburg State University. She is a national healthcare leader actively engaged in critical health, wellness, and education issues. Smolko is on the editorial board for The Soy Connection newsletter.
#  #  #
for the Soy Connection Health Professional Newsletter for the latest news on soy and opportunities to earn free CE credits.
All fields are required